Hmm, It sure looks good, but it's made very simple. But it hasn't that much flow and the vector isn't built in in the Wallpaper at all. I am not sure how overmare will rate them, but as a fromer signature banner designer with medium skills, I wouldn't rate that one to high, sry ^^
I'm rather attracted to it because of its simplicity. Granted, he would've tried some blending and perhaps another filtered layer, but I wouldn't count it out entirely. But I do see where you're coming from.
On another note, I think Overmare's actually going to have bystanders vote on the ones they like, rather then him just picking the top three.
Yeah, I don't say it's bad...it sure looks good even though it's so simple, but I like the other one, becuase I know hard it can be to do such a thing right ^^ I'll guess we'll see I hope I didn't sound arrogant before, if yes: sorry